-
My unpopular opinion: over-speccing measurement tools costs more than under-speccing them
-
Argument 1: The FARO laser tracker price tag is only the first invoice
-
Argument 2: The FARO Vantage laser tracker is unbeatable—for the work it was built for
-
Argument 3: A Mitutoyo 8 inch digital caliper outspeeds the tracker on the 80% job
-
A fair pushback: aren't you a FARO guy? Shouldn't you be pushing trackers?
My unpopular opinion: over-speccing measurement tools costs more than under-speccing them
I review about 200 measurement reports a quarter at an instrument company with three product lines in the metrology space. Somewhere around 30–40% of the jobs I audit are being done with a tool that costs five to fifty times more than the job actually requires. That's not a sales opportunity. That's a waste of money and time, and I've started calling it out.
Here's my stance: a FARO Vantage laser tracker is a phenomenal machine and it is the wrong answer for a huge chunk of the work people use it for. If that sounds like a strange thing for a guy in FARO's quality department to write, stick with me.
Argument 1: The FARO laser tracker price tag is only the first invoice
Publicly available pricing puts a complete FARO Vantage laser tracker setup somewhere in the low-to-mid six figures once you add the controller, targets, software seats, and the calibration package. That's the line item most buyers focus on.
What they miss—and what I see in every review that crosses my desk—is the cost of running it. A tracker needs a climate-controlled bay. It needs an operator who has been through real training, not a two-hour webinar. It needs setup time that's measured in tens of minutes, not seconds, because the whole point is a stable measurement volume, not quick-and-dirty checks. And it needs a calibration interval that's roughly annual if you want the numbers to mean anything.
Last year I audited a supplier's internal metrology spend for a joint program. They were using a tracker to verify bracket hole positions on a part roughly the size of a shoebox. Eleven setups a week. Each one took the better part of an hour including warm-up, reference, and teardown. They were paying trained engineers to do the work a $60 vernier caliper and a granite surface plate would have handled in four minutes.
Argument 2: The FARO Vantage laser tracker is unbeatable—for the work it was built for
I want to be precise about where this tool earns its price. In 2023, we ran a comparison for a customer flying large tooling assemblies: a 12-meter wing section fixture, sagging measurement points across the volume. A single Vantage setup covered it. Ground truth, one report, no stitching errors. The alternative would have been a dozen manual measurements with transfer standards and a lot of walking. That's not a luxury purchase. That's the right tool doing the job it was engineered for.
Same deal for wind tower sections, large molds, shipyard blocks, aerospace assembly jigs, anything where the measurement volume exceeds what a fixed CMM can hold and the parts can't be brought to a metrology lab. In those scenarios, hand tools aren't just slower—they're unreliable, because every transfer introduces error.
The question isn't "is this the best tool?" It's "is this the only tool that can do this job?" If the answer is yes, buy it. If the answer is no, run the math.
Argument 3: A Mitutoyo 8 inch digital caliper outspeeds the tracker on the 80% job
Here's the part that frustrates the sales side of this industry, and it's what prompted me to write this.
Most dimension checks in a production environment are length, thickness, diameter, or depth on a feature smaller than a hand. Flatness on a machined face. Runout on a shaft. Hole-to-edge distance on a stamped part. For those, a decent pair of vernier calipers or a Mitutoyo 8 inch digital caliper is not a downgrade. It's the correct instrument, and it hits 0.01 mm resolution with IP67 protection for around $200.
I know exactly where to buy a Mitutoyo 8 inch digital caliper—every industrial distributor in the country stocks it, and Mitutoyo's own site lists authorized dealers. That ubiquity matters. A caliper on the bench is a measuring tool that gets used. A tracker in a metrology bay across the building is a measuring tool that gets scheduled. And scheduled checks don't happen at the rate they should.
Last quarter I pulled three months of incoming inspection data from a plant that had bought a tracker for what was pitched as "full-fidelity dimensional control." The tracker ran 22 inspections in 90 days. The shop's calipers ran several hundred. The tracker wasn't measuring anything the calipers couldn't have measured. It was sitting in a room because using it took planning.
And the centrifuge 5424 question I get asked at trade shows—yes, lab equipment gets the same treatment. People search for a specific benchtop centrifuge model number, buy the bigger one, and then complain that the run time is too long for daily use. Same problem, different department.
A fair pushback: aren't you a FARO guy? Shouldn't you be pushing trackers?
Fair question. The honest answer is that our credibility dies the day we tell a customer to buy a six-figure system for a job a $200 caliper handles better. That's not a FARO position—that's a tax on the customer's trust. And I've watched companies lose measurement programs because they overspent early and then had no budget for the calibration and training that actually keep the numbers honest.
The Vantage is the right tool for large-volume, complex-geometry work where a CMM can't reach and hand tools can't verify. Full stop. If that's your situation, the price is justified and the results are unmatched. But if you're verifying hole positions on a machined bracket, calibrating a fixture, or checking a shaft diameter twice a shift, forcing that work onto a tracker doesn't make you more rigorous. It makes you slower, and eventually it makes you less accurate, because you'll stop running the checks.
My rule, after four years and a couple thousand reviewed reports: spec the smallest tool that can prove the tolerance. Then buy the tracker only when the alternative is a measurement you can't actually make. That's the honest version. It's also, I think, the version that keeps people coming back.